- McDonald's shared details of its new $8.5 billion "Next" initiative, and investors shrugged.
- With shares now at a four-year low, the company has to prove its US turnaround is working.
- Sign up for First Trade, Business Insider's daily markets newsletter.
If you've been inside a McDonald's lately, the most indelible image in your mind is probably a row of touchscreen ordering kiosks.
For digitally inclined people not looking for a conversation, they can be a savior. But there are plenty of others who don't want to handle their own keystrokes — who prefer to communicate with a human. Tough luck. These days, there might not be anyone working the counter at all.
These impersonal customer interactions are just one of the issues McDonald's is trying to address with its new "Next" initiative, which it detailed on Wednesday at its investor day.
The company will spend roughly $8.5 billion to help franchisees revamp their restaurants, aiming to improve food quality, streamline operations, and sharpen the customer experience. That means a bigger push into chicken and beverages, new equipment and restaurant designs, AI tools, and more hospitality training.
It all sounds good in theory. But the early reaction from investors was not particularly encouraging, as shares fell 5% on the day, hitting their lowest level since 2022. Wall Street appears skeptical that spending big to repair and modernize McDonald's core business will generate strong enough returns.
"Next" didn't create that skepticism. It simply gave investors a fresh reason to act on it. Which begs the question: What the heck is going on with McDonald's?
Why a reset is necessary
Let's start with the macro. The US economy is currently contending with a toxic mixture of weak retail sales, falling sentiment, and a contracting job market. That's resulted in a broad consumer pullback that's impacted not just McDonald's, but the entire discretionary sector, even Walmart.
Still, McDonald's hasn't simply been caught in an industrywide restaurant slump. Over the past five years, its shares have fallen 3%, while Restaurant Brands — Burger King's parent — is up 14% and Yum! Brands — owner of Taco Bell, KFC, and Pizza Hut — has gained 13%.
That performance gap points to a laundry list of McDonald's-specific problems: underperforming value deals, slowing US growth, falling guest counts, slipping service and satisfaction, and a disappointing World Cup promotion.
Enter Skye Anderson, a longtime McDonald's veteran who was announced last month as the company's new US president. She's tasked with overseeing the "Next" turnaround effort at a time when the consumer backdrop leaves little room for error.
The burden of proof
That leaves "Next" with a tricky assignment. McDonald's has to convince cash-strapped customers that it still offers real value — and that a more expensive, high-tech overhaul will actually improve the experience.
It also has to persuade franchisees that the investment will pay off, and show Wall Street that an expensive renovation of its core business can restart growth.
The plan is ultimately a "back to basics" play. There's no single fix-all promotion coming to the rescue. It's all about better food, faster service, and making customers feel more comfortable.
As a lifelong McDonald's patron and weekend breakfast regular, I know what would make me the happiest: the return of PlayPlaces. My kids need to know the joy of eating a Happy Meal while going down an indoor slide. Make it happen, Mickey D's.
The post McDonald’s is serving up an $8.5 billion McMakeover. Investors aren’t lovin’ it. appeared first on Business Insider
